The Oscars Got It Right: 10 Best Picture Wins That Truly Deserve the Spotlight
For all the hate we heap on the Oscars when our favourite movie or performance does not win, it is worth remembering that they actually get it right a lot of the time. Especially in recent years, thanks to the “new Academy,” the more diverse and culturally attuned membership welcomed over the past decade, we have finally seen a shift away from cookie-cutter, “Oscar-bait” films taking the gold toward movies that truly deserve it.
So what does it mean when the Oscars “get it right”? There are a few ways to gauge it, but the most reliable test is time. Some Best Picture winners fade into obscurity, looking at you, The Artist, while others endure as cultural touchstones, talked about decades later. Here are ten times the Academy absolutely nailed it.
1. Casablanca (1943)
If there is one film that epitomizes the very idea of a “classic,” it is Casablanca. It is a thrilling wartime romance with star power, gorgeously crafted cinema, and themes that resonate far beyond the screen. Released during World War II, it was not just entertainment. It was a timely meditation on courage, morality, and resistance against tyranny. A rare blend of art and mass appeal, Casablanca set the gold standard for what a Best Picture winner should be.
2. The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
To this day, it remains the only horror film to win Best Picture. Its sweep of the “Big Five” Oscars, Picture, Director, Actor, Actress, and Screenplay, cemented it in history. Beyond technical brilliance, it tapped into the cultural moment. The early 1990s saw a rise in public fascination with criminal profiling and the darker corners of human psychology. It is a masterclass in suspense, character, and storytelling that still holds up.
3. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003)
A fantasy epic breaking the Academy’s long-standing genre bias? Absolutely. Return of the King not only won eleven Oscars, every single one it was nominated for, it also rewarded Peter Jackson’s unprecedented feat of bringing a seemingly unfilmable trilogy to life. More than just a spectacle, it was epic storytelling at its finest, laying the groundwork for today’s cinematic universes while proving that big-budget blockbusters can also be Oscar-worthy.
4. Parasite (2019)
Historic and groundbreaking, it was the first non-English language film to win Best Picture and a triumph of the new Academy’s diversity and vision. Bong Joon-ho’s darkly comedic masterpiece blends social commentary, family drama, and suspense, weaving a story of class struggle that resonates universally. Its win marked a seismic shift, signaling that originality, cultural nuance, and risk-taking are finally being rewarded.
5. It Happened One Night (1934)
One of the first romantic comedies ever made, it revolutionized the genre with smart humour, swoon-worthy romance, and unforgettable chemistry between Clark Gable and Claudette Colbert. It is also one of the only films to sweep the Big Five. Popular, influential, and endlessly charming, this film defined what a rom-com could be and still remains a benchmark for the genre today.
6. Schindler’s List (1993)
Spielberg finally won the Oscar he deserved, and with this film, the Academy got it very right. Schindler’s List is not just cinematic perfection. Black-and-white cinematography, heart-wrenching performances, and meticulous direction combine to tell a story of monumental historical importance. Its cultural and educational impact is undeniable, bringing the realities of the Holocaust to audiences worldwide and serving as a vital reminder of history.
7. Everything Everywhere All at Once (2022)
An unconventional, offbeat sci-fi that snuck prestige into the multiverse. Amidst blockbusters and war dramas, this film’s win was a triumph for originality, world-building, and emotional depth. It is a family story, a comedy, an action epic, and a meditation on generational trauma all at once. By combining spectacle with intimate character work, it showcased cinematic ambition and talent both in front of and behind the camera.
8. The Departed (2006)
Yes, I am biased because this is my favourite film, but Scorsese was long overdue. The Departed blends crime thriller tension with moral complexity and boasts a stellar ensemble that is still talked about today. While often framed as a “makeup” Oscar for Goodfellas, this film stands on its own: taut, stylish, and emotionally resonant. It has aged beautifully and remains one of Scorsese’s best.
9. Amadeus (1984)
Artistry, storytelling, and spectacle collide in this period drama about jealousy, genius, and obsession. F. Murray Abraham’s Salieri is unforgettable, Tom Hulce’s Mozart is electric, and Miloš Forman’s direction balances drama, comedy, and visual grandeur perfectly. A biopic that transcends its genre, Amadeus is as entertaining as it is majestic and has retained its cultural weight for decades.
10. The Apartment (1960)
A comedy winning Best Picture is a big deal, and Billy Wilder had long been overdue for recognition. The Apartment is a sharp, socially aware story about love, ambition, and the moral compromises we make to get ahead. Jack Lemmon and Shirley MacLaine are brilliant, and Wilder’s deft hand at balancing comedy and drama shines through. Its win is both a celebration of a single film and a recognition of Wilder’s career-long excellence.
The takeaway? For all the missteps and snubs, the Oscars often get it right, especially when it comes to films that endure over time. Whether it is a daring, genre-defying epic, a culturally significant masterpiece, or a cleverly crafted comedy, these Best Picture winners show that the Academy can and does honour true excellence.
Binge. play. Watch. Repeat.
